14 Wedding First Dance Songs That Will Melt Your Heart

It’s here! The time for song selections has finally arrived on your wedding planning checklist. Processional–check. First dance–check. Bouquet toss–check. Now, there are two types of brides in this world: brides who have basically known since birth what songs they are going to walk down the aisle to and dance as Mr. & Mrs. for the first time to. It’s the song they grew up daydreaming about their Prince Charming to. It’s the song playing in the background of their first kiss. It’s the anthem for their relationship… And then there are brides who put off this decision until the night before their wedding and end up choosing whatever first comes to mind. While we definitely want the former type of bride to continue reading (it’s always nice to have options!), we’re here to help the latter type of bride overcome any procrastination. We’ve taken into account the romantic, make-you-melt kind of lyrics and beats you can actually dance to. From there, we have narrowed the list down to our top 14 favorite first dance songs to give you some inspiration.

Popular First Dance Songs. If you’re wanting a song your guests can sing along to while you waltz away, here are our top choices:

‘Make You Feel My Love’ by Adele

‘XO’ by John Mayer

‘Better Together’ by Jack Johnson

‘How Long Will I Love You’ by Ellie Goulding

‘You and I’ by Ingrid Michaelson

‘Come Away With Me’ by Norah Jones


Alternative First Dance Songs. If you’re looking for a more unconventional first dance song–you know, the kind of song your friends haven’t all chosen–weve’ve got you covered:

‘Sea of Love’ by Cat Power

‘Sparks’ by Coldplay

‘You Are the Best Thing’ by Ray LaMontagne

‘Heart’s on Fire’ by Passenger

‘My Two Left Feet’ by Erick Baker


Classic first dance songs. Because they just never seem to get old… If you’re afraid the classics are all overused, search for covers of older songs. Same tune, fresh vocals! It was hard to narrow down, but here’s a few of our favorite throwbacks:

‘The Way You Look Tonight’ by Frank Sinatra

‘At Last’ by Etta James (or pump up the younger crowd with a little Beyonce)

‘Can’t Help Falling In Love With You’ by Haley Reinhart

Choosing Castleton Farms: Our Exclusive Wedding Vendors

Wedding vendors portfolio and work

As we continue our countdown, we must ask, have you ever fallen in love?  If you are still crushing on our venue, but not actually made the commitment yet, maybe #7 will change your mind – our amazingly talented wedding vendors! At Castleton Farms, we have worked with many professionals and have found that our vendors are the best-of-the-best in the industry!  They have each won various awards in their chosen fields and are completely competent to exceed your expectations. Could you imagine your wedding without food, pictures, makeup, linens, tables and chairs or wedding décor?  What about a cake, drinks, music, videos, lights or flowers? Without those items, it doesn’t sound like a dream wedding, does it? Your vendors are such an intricate part of this day. They are like the branches on the tree that you have planted. They take your inspiration and put it into action by using your thoughts, your ideas and your dreams. No one should share their dream wedding with just anyone–you must use vendors that are foolproof. That’s why Castleton has completed all the research for you and chosen some of the best-of-the-best in the industry.  Allow us to introduce you to our Castleton vendors. I promise you can’t help but fall in love with these professionals!

Tilley_Jones_WatsonStudios_kendracodyw0390b copy


Bangs and Blush

All Occasions Party Rentals

All Occasion Catering

Corks Wine & Spirits

Samuel Franklin Flowers

Unique Settings and Mismatched China Rentals

Ben Finch Photography

Bill Waldorf Photography

Cody Myers Photography

Katherine Birkbeck Photography

Bryan Allen Photography

Jennie Andrews Photography

Tracie Ancelet Photography

Julie Roberts Photography

Milestone Pictures

Casey & Kristin

Alex Widmer Video

Special Notes

Ogle Entertainment

The Happy Envelope